Butterscotch Whoopie Pies

June 9, 2017



These American classics get a british makeover in my new butterscotch whoopie pies recipe!

I must admit there is more than just a butterscotch sauce in these great new treats - my secret is putting cinnamon and some nutmeg into the cake itself so that the sweetness is combated by the spice from the warming cinnamon. These have been such a hit with my family and friends who have  tasted them and I am very pleased to be able to share this new recipe so that you can try this out as well!




For the Pies

- 300g Plain flour

- 2tsp Baking powder

- 1.5tsp Ground cinnamon

- 0.5 tsp Ground nutmeg

- 250ml Milk

- 1tsp Vanilla extract

- 5 tbsp Butter

- 100g Granulated sugar

-100g Light brown sugar

- 1 egg


For the butterscotch sauce

- 200g Granulated sugar

-90g Butter (unsalted)

-115ml Double cream


For the filling

- 165g Butter (softened)

-200g Icing sugar

- 2-3 tbsp Butterscotch sauce





- Grease two baking sheets and preheat your oven to 185 degrees (fan)


- Begin by combining flour, baking powder and spices in a bowl.


- Pour milk and vanilla extract into a jug and mix slightly.


- Cream the butter and sugars into a bowl before adding the egg and beating for around 2 minutes.


- Add in the flour to this mixture in two stages, alternating with additions of milk before mixing for around 5 minutes.


- Pour mixture into a piping bag and pipe onto your baking sheets in small circles.


- Bake for around 12 - 15 minutes before removing from the oven to cool.


- Meanwhile create the butterscotch sauce by heating the sugar in a pan on a medium heat until fully melted and golden brown.


- Remove from the heat, add the butter, stirring constantly until it has melted before pouring in the double cream. Stir until no patches of white cream can be found.


- Leave to cool completely (this is important as it will otherwise melt the butter in the filling !)


- To make the filling cream the butter and sugar completely before beating in the butterscotch sauce.


- Pipe filling onto one of the sponges and sandwich it by placing another sponge on top of it.


- To decorate try drizzling left over sauce over the whoopie pies.


- Eat fresh for the best result !



Subscribe for regular updates on all my latest recipes and please do share with your friends and family!








Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Please reload

August 2, 2019

January 9, 2019

October 30, 2018

September 24, 2018

September 4, 2018

April 30, 2018

Please reload

Benji's Baking | benjis_baking@hotmail.com | United Kingdom

© 2020 by Benji's Baking
  • Snapchat